How to Deal with Post-Pitch Panic and Get Your Piece Written

In Tips & Tricks by Christine Organ | |

How to Deal with Post-Pitch Panic and Get Your Piece Written - by Christine Organ on Beyond Your Blog
Over the course of my career as a writer, I have realized two certainties about submitting my work to other sites. The first certainty is rejection. If you submit enough, rejections are just part of the game. Fortunately, because rejection is an oft-discussed topic for writers, I was prepared for it. That doesn’t mean the rejections are easy, just that I knew that they would happen and had countless places to turn for support and advice on how to deal with rejection.
It is the second certainty of professional writing, however, that caught me completely off-guard: Post-Pitch Panic.
How to Deal with Post-Pitch Panic and Get Your Piece Written - By Christine Organ on Beyond Your Blog 
Whether I feel Post-Pitch Panic after I pitch a topic to an editor at a new-to-me site, or after I suggest an idea to the editor of a site I write for regularly, or even after that lightbulb story idea goes off in my head, Post-Pitch Panic usually looks something like this in my head:
Your idea stinks.
You have no idea what you’re doing.
You are not talented/smart enough to write about this.
This idea is boring and uninteresting.
There’s nothing more to say about this topic; it’s all been done before.
You can’t do it.
At first, Post-Pitch Panic totally threw me off my game. I let pieces go unwritten or put off writing them until the very last-minute. But by now, I’m able to recognize these self-destructive thoughts as a manifestation of Post-Pitch Panic and promptly tell those voices to shut the heck up so I can get to work. Here are a few of the strategies I have learned to work through Post-Pitch Panic and get the piece written.
  • Outline. Many times the panic I feel comes from my inability to put thoughts into coherent sentences – much less sentences that have any semblance of structure and order. If this is the case, I find it best to jot down ideas and key points to the topic as an outline. Then I can work to rearrange the key points in a way that makes sense before working to fill in the holes and expand the headings into paragraphs.
5 Strategies To Combat Post-Pitch Panic Click To Tweet
  • Brainstorm. This strategy works best when the finished piece will likely be an expanded list, or it is a piece on a highly emotional topic. In either case, writing down words can help get the creative juices flowing. Once I have written down several words or phrases, a theme often emerges which can help direct the writing process.
  • Freewrite. If my thoughts are semi-coherent, but I’m having trouble connecting the dots, so to speak, freewriting is most helpful. In a freewrite, I will simply write, write, write without worrying about grammar, spelling, or flow. Avoiding self-editing can be difficult during a freewrite, but I remind myself that many of the writing greats like Anne Lamott were staunch proponents of the “crappy first draft” so it’s worth a try.
  • Continue the pitch. Chances are the “pitch” started somewhere – whether it was a proposed headline sent to an editor I work with on a regular basis, a 1-2 sentence description of the piece sent to a new editor, a rambling diatribe in my head during my morning run, or a feeling I couldn’t quite name but knew was worth writing about. By combining several of the aforementioned techniques, such as freewriting and outlining – I will take that “pitch” and expand it, without thinking of it as a possible finished piece. I might expand the headline into a paragraph (but usually not the first paragraph since first paragraphs are often the most difficult for me to write), or I will take the 1-2 sentence description and expand them until I’ve written a couple paragraphs. Or I will imagine I am writing a note to a friend about that amorphous “feeling” until the core of the piece emerges.
  • Edit. Edit. Edit. This step is CRITICAL. Because it is my reliance on the editing process that allows me to work through each of the various techniques. Without the editing process, the “piece” wouldn’t really be a “piece” at all, but just a jumble of words. Because I know and trust the editing process so well, however, I can silence the mean and nasty voices of Post-Pitch Panic and the ones that like to pipe up from time to time during the drafting stages as well. 
Silence the mean and nasty voices of Post-Pitch Panic! Click To Tweet
Regardless of how you deal with Post-Pitch Panic, and which techniques you use, don’t be afraid to pivot or take the piece in a different direction. If the finished piece doesn’t work for the site you had originally planned, chances are it will be a good fit for a different site.

So next time you experience Post-Pitch Panic, you can tell those voices to HUSH UP because you’ve got work to do – and that piece isn’t going to write itself!

How to Deal with Post-Pitch Panic and Get Your Piece Written - by Christine Organ on Beyond Your Blog

About the Author

Christine Organ

Christine Organ is the author of Open Boxes: The Gifts of Living a Full and Connected Life, which is a collection of essays that celebrate the fullness of life. Her work has been published on The New York Times, Washington Post, Huffington Post, Scary Mommy, Club Mid, BonBon Break, and Mamalode. When she isn’t chasing around her two boys or scolding her two ill-behaved dogs, she writes at